Posted by: biblioglobal | June 26, 2012

Egypt (Book from every country #15)

Woman at Point Zero by Nawal El Saadawi

How I found this book: One of the interesting and unexpected things about having a blog is that WordPress tells me the Google searches that lead people to my blog. Unfortunately, for some reason the search terms that show up are rarely very relevant to the content of my blog. A case in point- a while ago the search term “compare breath eyes memory woman at point zero” popped up. I had reviewed Breath, Eyes, Memory so this was at least vaguely relevant, but I didn’t even know what “woman at point zero” was. I looked it up and it turned out to be a short feminist novel written by an Egyptian woman in the 1970s.

My thoughts:

Woman at Point Zero is the tale of Firdaus, a woman on death row for killing a man. There is an interesting preface by the author, which explains that the novel is based on a woman she met while visiting an Egyptian prison as a doctor. Ironically, Nawal El Saadawi herself was later jailed in the same prison as a result of her political views.

Early on I found the book a bit heavy-handed as everything bad that could possibly happen to a woman seemed to happen to Firdaus in quick succession- molestation, female circumcision, spousal abuse, prostitution, not to mention general disrespect as a women. The book is so short, just over 100 pages, that this all happened too quickly without the chance for Firdaus to develop as a character. As I got further into the book though, I came to recognize  that the book is a political statement as much as it is a novel. Somehow,  seeing it this way helped my to enjoy the book much more.

Woman at Point Zero makes the rather radical argument that Firdaus is better off as a prostitute (so long as she is able to work independently) than in following any of her other options. I don’t think that this is meant to indicate that prostitution is such a great option, but rather that all of her other options are even worse. While I may not agree with the conclusion that prostitution is her best option, it is striking that Firdaus’s position in society was so bad a plausible argument for it can be made.

What really made this book worthwhile for me was the scene when Firdaus first receives money in exchange for sex. This, unexpectedly, is a moment of empowerment for her. This is the first time in her life that she has money of her own. She had been a prostitute before, but the money was always taken by the man or woman controlling her. Before that she had always been dependent on her family or her husband. Firdaus takes the money she has earned and uses some of it to buy food for herself in a restaurant. For the first time in her life, she is able to eat as much as she wants without someone watching her plate and begrudging the cost of her food. Having money gives her a new-found feeling of power  and she walks down the street with her head held high.

Advertisements

Responses

  1. i tried to read this book years ago and remember hating it. your review makes me want to retry it – so i shall.

    re the list: i too will have it just for options. i was surprised at how many ‘foreign ‘books my really small local library has. what i like about this idea is that i shall be exposed to all sorts of new authors and i don;t want to lose the serendipity of that by having a strict list of any sort

    ps – are you on goodreads?

    • As you can see, I had somewhat mixed feelings about the book. It definitely had weaknesses, but I got some things out of reading nonetheless.

      I’ve toyed with the idea, but nope I’m not on goodreads.

  2. […] first half of The Story of Zahra by Hanan al-Shaykh reminded me a lot of the first half of Woman at Point Zero. In both, the heroine just keeps on being mistreated by one person after another- their parents, […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: